Comparable vs Comparator in Java
Java provides two interfaces to sort objects using data members of the class:
- Comparable
- Comparator
Using Comparable Interface
A comparable object is capable of comparing itself with another object. The class itself must implements the java.lang.Comparable interface to compare its instances.
Consider a Movie class that has members like, rating, name, year. Suppose we wish to sort a list of Movies based on year of release. We can implement the Comparable interface with the Movie class, and we override the method compareTo() of Comparable interface.
// A Java program to demonstrate use of Comparable import java.io.*; import java.util.*; // A class 'Movie' that implements Comparable class Movie implements Comparable<Movie> { private double rating; private String name; private int year; // Used to sort movies by year public int compareTo(Movie m) { return this .year - m.year; } // Constructor public Movie(String nm, double rt, int yr) { this .name = nm; this .rating = rt; this .year = yr; } // Getter methods for accessing private data public double getRating() { return rating; } public String getName() { return name; } public int getYear() { return year; } } // Driver class class Main { public static void main(String[] args) { ArrayList<Movie> list = new ArrayList<Movie>(); list.add( new Movie( "Force Awakens" , 8.3 , 2015 )); list.add( new Movie( "Star Wars" , 8.7 , 1977 )); list.add( new Movie( "Empire Strikes Back" , 8.8 , 1980 )); list.add( new Movie( "Return of the Jedi" , 8.4 , 1983 )); Collections.sort(list); System.out.println( "Movies after sorting : " ); for (Movie movie: list) { System.out.println(movie.getName() + " " + movie.getRating() + " " + movie.getYear()); } } } |
Copy CodeRun on IDE
Output:
Movies after sorting : Star Wars 8.7 1977Empire Strikes Back 8.8 1980Return of the Jedi 8.4 1983Force Awakens 8.3 2015
Now, suppose we want sort movies by their rating and names also. When we make a collection element comparable(by having it implement Comparable), we get only one chance to implement the compareTo() method. The solution is using
Using Comparator
Unlike Comparable, Comparator is external to the element type we are comparing. It’s a separate class. We create multiple separate classes (that implement Comparator) to compare by different members.
Collections class has a second sort() method and it takes Comparator. The sort() method invokes the compare() to sort objects.
To compare movies by Rating, we need to do 3 things :
- Create a class that implements Comparator (and thus the compare() method that does the work previously done by compareTo()).
- Make an instance of the Comparator class.
- Call the overloaded sort() method, giving it both the list and the instance of the class that implements Comparator.
//A Java program to demonstrate Comparator interface import java.io.*; import java.util.*; // A class 'Movie' that implements Comparable class Movie implements Comparable<Movie> { private double rating; private String name; private int year; // Used to sort movies by year public int compareTo(Movie m) { return this .year - m.year; } // Constructor public Movie(String nm, double rt, int yr) { this .name = nm; this .rating = rt; this .year = yr; } // Getter methods for accessing private data public double getRating() { return rating; } public String getName() { return name; } public int getYear() { return year; } } // Class to compare Movies by ratings class RatingCompare implements Comparator<Movie> { public int compare(Movie m1, Movie m2) { if (m1.getRating() < m2.getRating()) return - 1 ; if (m1.getRating() > m2.getRating()) return 1 ; else return 0 ; } } // Class to compare Movies by name class NameCompare implements Comparator<Movie> { public int compare(Movie m1, Movie m2) { return m1.getName().compareTo(m2.getName()); } } // Driver class class Main { public static void main(String[] args) { ArrayList<Movie> list = new ArrayList<Movie>(); list.add( new Movie( "Force Awakens" , 8.3 , 2015 )); list.add( new Movie( "Star Wars" , 8.7 , 1977 )); list.add( new Movie( "Empire Strikes Back" , 8.8 , 1980 )); list.add( new Movie( "Return of the Jedi" , 8.4 , 1983 )); // Sort by rating : (1) Create an object of ratingCompare // (2) Call Collections.sort // (3) Print Sorted list System.out.println( "Sorted by rating" ); RatingCompare ratingCompare = new RatingCompare(); Collections.sort(list, ratingCompare); for (Movie movie: list) System.out.println(movie.getRating() + " " + movie.getName() + " " + movie.getYear()); // Call overloaded sort method with RatingCompare // (Same three steps as above) System.out.println( "\nSorted by name" ); NameCompare nameCompare = new NameCompare(); Collections.sort(list, nameCompare); for (Movie movie: list) System.out.println(movie.getName() + " " + movie.getRating() + " " + movie.getYear()); // Uses Comparable to sort by year System.out.println( "\nSorted by year" ); Collections.sort(list); for (Movie movie: list) System.out.println(movie.getYear() + " " + movie.getRating() + " " + movie.getName()+ " " ); } } |
Copy CodeRun on IDE
Output :
Sorted by rating8.3 Force Awakens 20158.4 Return of the Jedi 19838.7 Star Wars 19778.8 Empire Strikes Back 1980Sorted by nameEmpire Strikes Back 8.8 1980Force Awakens 8.3 2015Return of the Jedi 8.4 1983Star Wars 8.7 1977Sorted by year1977 8.7 Star Wars 1980 8.8 Empire Strikes Back 1983 8.4 Return of the Jedi 2015 8.3 Force Awakens
- Comparable is meant for objects with natural ordering which means the object itself must know how it is to be ordered. For example Roll Numbers of students. Whereas, Comparator interface sorting is done through a separate class.
- Logically, Comparable interface compares “this” reference with the object specified and Comparator in Java compares two different class objects provided.
- If any class implements Comparable interface in Java then collection of that object either List or Array can be sorted automatically by using Collections.sort() or Arrays.sort() method and objects will be sorted based on there natural order defined by CompareTo method.
To summarize, if sorting of objects needs to be based on natural order then use Comparable whereas if you sorting needs to be done on attributes of different objects, then use Comparator in Java.
This article is contributed by Souradeep Barua. Please write comments if you find anything incorrect, or you want to share more information about the topic discussed above
Reference:
https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/comparable-vs-comparator-in-java/